Meta Faces $887 Million Fine Over Facebook Gallery Access in Italy
- Daniel Kamberski
- 315 reads
Italy’s Garante says Facebook’s shared Android permission failed to explain gallery suggestions to about 20 million users. Meta plans to appeal.

Facebook’s Android gallery suggestions put a design question at the center of an €805 million ($887 million) fine in Italy: does one broad permission clearly cover several app functions with different purposes? Italy’s data protection authority, the Garante, says users weren’t adequately informed that enabling other features also allowed Facebook to suggest photos and videos from their phone galleries. Meta disputes the finding and says it will appeal.

The feature, available since 2023, offers photos and videos from a device’s gallery as possible material for posts while someone browses Facebook. It also accesses associated metadata, such as when an image was taken. The Garante says the app sought gallery access through a permission shared across the app, even though the permission covered functions with different needs.
That distinction matters in interface design. A device prompt can communicate that an app wants access to a resource, while leaving users unclear about which feature will use it and for what purpose. In the Garante’s view, a general notice about enabling other Facebook functions didn’t make the gallery suggestion feature clear enough for users to make a specific choice.
What the Garante’s decision covers
The authority’s decision document says the permission wasn’t specific and users didn’t receive adequate information. The Garante cited Article 122 of Italy’s privacy code, which implements the EU ePrivacy directive. As reported by the news agency ANSA, the cited provision requires free and informed consent whether or not data is transmitted or harm results.
The finding concerns Android users in Italy. The Garante put the number of people involved at about 20 million and considered that figure when setting the fine. It also said the issue remains ongoing for people who haven’t updated the app and for those who had already granted the permission.
For the amount, the authority also considered a 2019 decision involving Meta and what it described as poor cooperation during its investigation. Italian media reports put the fine at about 0.47 percent of Meta’s global turnover. The Garante fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited.
Changes required by the order
The Garante ordered Meta to keep the gallery suggestion feature switched off by default and obtain consent through a separate, specific request. That request must explain what the feature does, state that it accesses the device gallery and tell users how to turn it off. The deadline for those changes is 60 days.
For app teams, the dispute highlights the practical gap between a system-level permission and a user’s understanding of a particular feature. A permission may technically allow an app to reach a device resource, but the surrounding explanation and the timing of the request shape what users can reasonably understand they are enabling. Here, the authority’s remedy calls for a distinct request that names the gallery use and gives users a way to disable it.
Meta’s response and unresolved questions
A Meta spokesperson said the company strongly disagrees with the Garante’s interpretation of the facts and its application of the law, and called the fine disproportionate. ANSA reported that the spokesperson characterized the feature as a simple aid to posting, available only after device authorization and adjustable in settings. The Garante, in turn, treated Meta’s later changes as late and as only partly mitigating the matter.
The case therefore turns on more than whether a user authorized gallery access at some point. The central dispute is whether the request and its explanation made the particular use understandable, and whether the choice was sufficiently separate from permissions serving other functions. Meta’s planned appeal leaves those findings open to challenge.
The Garante said its proceeding did not examine whether Meta used gallery content to train AI models; Meta denies doing so. The authority also reserved the option to assess separately a newer feature, launched in 2026, that processes gallery content in the cloud. That feature falls outside the scope of the current order.
The decision was announced Nov. 14 and applies to Facebook’s Android app and users in Italy. The immediate engineering and product question is whether Meta’s revised consent request meets the Garante’s requirements within 60 days; the appeal will determine how the contested findings are tested.