Skip to the stories
Mechanical & Manufacturing

Jackdaw Gas Field Approval Splits Engineers on Security, Emissions and Jobs

  • David Rodriguez
  • 709 reads

Jackdaw may add domestic gas supply, but its emissions and limited jobs sharpen debate over energy security and the UK’s transition.

Jackdaw Gas Field Approval Splits Engineers on Security, Emissions and Jobs

Jackdaw’s approval puts a specific trade-off back in focus for UK energy engineers: a new domestic gas source may support supply security, but its effect on global emissions and consumer bills is disputed. The field could produce its first gas by the end of this month, after nearly two years of uncertainty over whether its climate impacts had been adequately assessed.

The decision followed a Scottish court ruling last January that the effects of burning Jackdaw gas on global emissions had to be considered before the project could proceed. Former developer Shell and current owner Adura supplied further evidence arguing that the development is consistent with net-zero goals. The resulting assessment concluded that Jackdaw would not prevent the UK from meeting its targets.

Security is the clearest argument for production

Sanjoy Sen, a member of the Institution of Chemical Engineers’ oil, gas and energy transition special interest group committee, described the decision as an “enabler to the energy transition”. He pointed to renewables supplying more than half of UK electricity, while new-build nuclear capacity is not yet operating and imported gas supplies remain exposed to global tensions. In his view, Jackdaw can help support domestic energy security over the coming decade.

Other engineers see that case, but weigh it against the need to reduce fossil fuel use. Geraint Evans, former chair of IChemE’s clean energy special interest group, said he had “mixed emotions”. He called approval a step backwards given the urgency of reaching net zero, while also recognising the value of energy security. “I would rather not support it, but I do,” he said.

Tom Baxter, a University of Aberdeen lecturer and IChemE Fellow, also identified security of supply as Jackdaw’s strongest case. He said replacing some imported liquefied natural gas (LNG) from the US with domestic gas might bring a slight climate benefit, because US LNG has higher production emissions. But he expects the effect on global emissions to be too small to measure.

Gas sources have different emissions intensities

Adura’s emissions case rests partly on comparing Jackdaw with US LNG. The company cited an average of 85 kgCO2e per barrel of oil equivalent (boe) for US LNG production, against an expected 18.5 kgCO2e/boe for Jackdaw. That comparison matters, but it does not describe the UK’s full gas supply mix.

LNG currently supplies 20% of UK gas demand. Norwegian pipeline gas supplies 37%, with an emissions intensity of 8 kgCO2e/boe. Adura argued that Norwegian pipeline capacity was already fully used. The assessment rejected that as a general description: capacity constraints apply during periods of high winter demand, while other periods could see increased Norwegian flows if Jackdaw did not produce, alongside supply from other sources, including LNG.

There is also a platform-level consequence. Adding Jackdaw production is expected to raise the overall production intensity of the Shearwater platform above the UK Continental Shelf average, to 31 kgCO2e/boe. That figure complicates the comparison with imported LNG: the emissions case depends on which supply Jackdaw displaces and when, as well as on the added production emissions at Shearwater.

Jobs and bills are limited parts of the case

Jackdaw will operate as a normally unmanned installation. The project is expected to create 27 jobs and safeguard 273 existing jobs on Adura’s Shearwater platform, where the gas will be processed. Baxter expects little effect on chemical engineering employment in north-east Scotland. The project could help sustain skills and create “one or maybe two” process engineering jobs, he said, but most local benefits are likely to be marginal.

Claims about energy bills also need careful reading. One public statement linked a pragmatic approach to North Sea production with lower bills. Yet the 92-page decision document said Jackdaw would not materially affect energy prices or consumer bills, because the UK is a price-taker in global oil and gas markets. The assessment assigned the project’s bill impact “negligible” weight. Domestic production may change where some gas comes from; the stated assessment does not expect it to set prices for consumers.

Rosebank raises the stakes

Attention now turns to Adura’s larger Rosebank oil field, west of Shetland. Jackdaw’s total maximum emissions from production and combustion are estimated at 36m tonnes of CO2e. Rosebank could be responsible for 250m tonnes of CO2e. Most Jackdaw gas is expected to be burned in the UK, whereas much of Rosebank’s oil is likely to be exported for refining abroad, given the UK’s limited refining capacity.

Adura chief executive Neil McCulloch said the company believes the case for Rosebank is equally strong and expects an evidence-based assessment to support approval. Richard Clarke, a climate specialist and IChemE Fellow, warned that using Jackdaw as a precedent for Rosebank could increase exposure to heatwaves and storms without doing much to improve supply security or prices. He argued that the UK should speed up the shift to low-carbon energy sources and storage.

Jackdaw’s practical value will depend on more than its expected production intensity. The key questions are how much gas it supplies during periods of tight demand, which imports it displaces, and how those effects compare with the added emissions from production and combustion. Its limited staffing footprint also suggests a modest contribution to regional engineering employment. The Rosebank decision will test whether the same balance of supply, jobs and climate evidence leads to a different conclusion at a much larger emissions scale.

Source: David Rodriguez · www.thechemicalengineer.com

From the same set