Skip to the stories
Mechanical & Manufacturing

GB Chemical Approval Rules Face Challenge Over Fast Track Scheme

  • John Martinez
  • 554 reads

A campaign group is challenging GB rules that can approve chemicals based on assessments in other countries, raising questions about scope and oversight.

GB Chemical Approval Rules Face Challenge Over Fast Track Scheme

The key change in Great Britain’s chemical approval process is the use of assessments from other countries to speed decisions. Rules that came into force in May 2026 provide for chemicals already approved in countries with a “similar” regulatory framework and a “transparent” classification process to be approved by default. A campaign group, Fighting Dirty, is challenging how that scheme was introduced and how widely it may apply.

The group has filed a claim against the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) in the High Court in London. Its argument is that an amendment to existing regulations was made unlawfully. A judge will decide whether the claim can proceed to a full judicial review; a decision is expected within two to four months. That decision concerns whether the challenge can advance, rather than whether the scheme itself meets the group’s objections.

How the fast track changes approval

Before the new regime, potentially hazardous chemicals were subject to an HSE approval process before being placed on the GB market. The fast track changes the route for substances that already have approval in qualifying countries: instead of requiring a separate assessment from the outset, the rules provide for approval by default if the country meets the stated criteria.

Those criteria turn on two broad judgements: whether another country’s regulatory framework is sufficiently similar to Britain’s, and whether its classification process is transparent. The source material does not specify a technical test for either judgement, or detail how individual substances will be assessed under the scheme. In practice, the scope of the route therefore depends on which countries qualify and how the HSE applies those tests.

That distinction matters to chemical manufacturers and users. Reliance on another country’s assessment could reduce duplicated work and shorten the route to market for substances already reviewed elsewhere. But it also makes the quality and relevance of the underlying assessment central. Different systems may classify hazards or evaluate evidence differently; the fast track’s stated criteria are intended to address comparability, though their application will determine how that works in individual cases.

Dispute over which countries qualify

In a consultation response issued in February, the HSE said the proposed fast track would be “restricted to the EU”. Fighting Dirty argues that the rules were later applied to a wider, unspecified set of countries without another consultation. The group says that this change in scope was unlawful.

The campaigners contend that the wider approach could allow chemicals approved in countries whose standards they consider weaker, naming the US and Brazil as examples. The rules described in the source do not name those countries as qualifying, however. Whether either could use the route would depend on the HSE’s assessment against the similarity and transparency criteria.

For companies working with chemical approvals, the immediate practical question is how the HSE will identify eligible countries and communicate those decisions. A clear, consistent process would help firms understand whether an existing foreign approval can support access to the GB market. The pending case instead focuses on whether the process was introduced in a way the group says kept faith with what the public had been told.

Capacity and alignment

The HSE has been responsible for developing new chemical rules since the UK left the EU. On the day the fast track took effect, civil servants speaking at the ChemUK trade show described a “significant workload” associated with Brexit. An official from the Department for Environment and Rural Affairs said GB rules would be near-identical to EU rules, “diverging only where necessary”, to avoid duplicating EU assessments in a way described as time-consuming and costly.

That aim and the fast track address related pressures: maintaining a functioning approval system while limiting repeated assessments. The engineering and process trade-off is familiar in safety review. Reusing another system’s work can save time, but it relies on confidence that the evidence, classifications and review methods are suitable for the receiving market. The available details do not establish how the HSE will resolve those questions substance by substance.

Fighting Dirty founder Georgia Elliott-Smith pointed to pollution in Thornton-Cleveleys as an example of the human consequences she associates with slow or insufficient regulation of substances such as PFAS. She said the new regime gives the HSE discretion to decide which countries qualify without an independent check. The group’s claim, she stressed, concerns whether the rules were introduced lawfully and whether commitments made during consultation were kept.

The HSE said it would not comment on ongoing proceedings. The Department for Work and Pensions did not respond to a request for comment. The next concrete milestone is the judge’s decision on whether the claim proceeds to a full review. For chemical users and manufacturers, the longer-term point to watch is how eligibility criteria are defined and applied, since that will determine when an existing approval elsewhere can replace a separate GB assessment.

Source: John Martinez · www.thechemicalengineer.com

From the same set